If there is a connection, it would appear to be way back in Germany. Peter Reinheimer left Horschbach (Germany) 18 May 1848. Arrived in London 24 May, boarded a ship 1 Jun and arrived in New York 9 Jul 1848. He then arrived in Sandusky, Ohio on 21 July 1848.
To the best of my knowledge, all my Reinheimers lived in Sandusky and went to Zion Lutheran Church.