Search for content in message boards

Robert Robin Smith and Martha Clover

Robert Robin Smith and Martha Clover

Posted: 1384625616000
Classification: Biography
I'm trying to find out the relationship of Robert Smith (Ir) and Phillip Clover (who is listed as Robert's father).. Robert married Martha Clover (Phillip's daughter). John Smith married Jane Jenny Downes the parents of Sarah Anne, my 2nd Great Grandmother.

Re: Robert Robin Smith and Martha Clover

Posted: 1392160959000
Classification: Query
Where did you see Philip Clover listed as Robert Smith's father? This is incorrect. I don't think you will find a primary source that states this.
If you only saw this in someone's tree, then you are seeing a mistake. A possible source of confusion may be a DAR/SAR application. There are at least two SAR applications on Ancestry that include Robert Smith. These applications shift between maternal lines and paternal lines as needed to establish descent. They list the penultimate ancestral generation as Robert Smith Sr and Martha Clover, and the ultimate ancestral generation as Philip Clover and Mary Cooper. This means they trace their descent from Philip Clover, the veteran of the Revolutionary War, through Martha and Robert, not that Robert is a son of the Clovers.
You can never trust the trees posted on ancestry unless there is linked material to back it up. Many users are very careless with linking and adding relatives.
per page

Find a board about a specific topic