I am searching for Catherine's brother Joshua Vance. I believe he is her sister because both Catherine Vance and Margaret Vance married Shaw brothers and in a 1904 newspaper article in the Daily Courier of Connellsville it mentions that Catherine Vance Shaw was the sister of the recently departed Joshua Vance. Joshua died late enough that his obituary would be in the Courier except that several days are missing that would contain the obit. This is one of may most frustrating Obits. Several family trees suggest that a son of Moses Vance was their father but he would have had to be too young to father the children.