I know the email above is old, but I am hoping this reaches you. I may be able to help you with you "Susie " TEAGLE, B. SC, 1851.
Write me at ftrandalludc@ gmail.com
The TEAGLE family that I am descended from always used Susanna and called the child Susie" from what I have found over several generations. If you get this, be sure to be in touch.