Looking at the 1870 Census for Lawrence County,Upper Twsp., OH. I find 5 of George and Menima Ramsbottom's children; William, Berriman, John, Letta and James. This is definitly my family. It also matches your James b. 1869 with this family. So.... I am now 99.9% sure that our George's are one and the same!!!
Any thoughts or questions??