I wonder if you are researching the same family that I am and not having much luck. My gggrandfather was Thomas Kimble, b. 1817 in NJ. He m. Mary Ann Wells, b 1817/18 NY. They named their first child Sarah J. They were in Allen Co, IN, Cedar Cr. in 1850. They moved on to Van Buren Co, IA. However by this time Sarah had married.
I've never goten any further. Would like to know his parents and siblings. I wonder if your Sarah could be a sister to my Thomas.