If the marriage date is correct ... then Hannah Jurilla HOOBER/HOOVER would be a wife #2.??? I don't have anything about a wife#1. ..... and I don't have Robert on the 1870 census? That would be a BIG asset............ AND someone reported that Hannah Jurilla's maiden name was SMITH not HOOBER which is what I have .... MMMM - more mess - more mystery!! AND the 1880 Clinton Co Pa census shows that Scott was a popular name for the KERSTETTER clan...............!
I have Robert Scott KARSTETTER as a son of William KARSTETTER 6 Oct 1821 and Anna GLANTZ 9 Sep 1823......
1880 Logansville, Clinton, Pa 1255113 T9-1113 592A
Scott KARSTETTER Self M Male W 26 PA HiredHand PA PA
Lydia A. KARSTETTER Wife M Female W 20 PA KeepHouse PA PA
1880 Greene, Clinton, Pa 1255113 T9-1113 599C
Robert S. KARSTETLER Self M Male W 30 PA Laborer PA PA
Hannah J. KARSTETLER Wife M Female W 26 PA Keeping House PA PA
Charles H. KARSTETLER Son S Male W 11 PA At Home PA PA
William L. KARSTETLER Son S Male W 8 PA PA PA
Mary F. KARSTETLER Dau S Female W 6 PA PA PA
George W. KARSTETLER Son S Male W 3 PA PA PA