Can I suggest we get together? I agree with you that some information that some of us have needs to be sorted out before distributing it etc.
I have been in contact with the following people perhaps you have as well:
Nancy (Carroll) Lewis Husband was Clyde Lewis
Jean (Spears) Carroll Husband was Martin Carroll and The line of Carroll's that I am researching mostly is my daughter in-laws mother's line. This line is located in Dartmouth NS.They descend from the Mathew Line who is the son of Patrick Carroll and Nancy Barbra Langille.
Mathew's son George W H Carroll moved to Dartmouth in the early 1900s.
I would like to share what I have and maybe together we can support our information with certainty before releasing any of it.
Have A Great Day!
My personal email is firstname.lastname@example.org