I'm not related to any member of this family.
Facts you should be aware of -
1850, 1860 & 1870 census records do not show family relationships or parental birthplaces.
Name: Benjamin Reynolds
Birth Year: abt 1854
Age in 1870: 16
Home in 1870: Farmington, Jefferson, Wisconsin
Washington Reynolds 49, NY - farmer
Mary Reynolds 28, NY [2nd wife??]
Benjamin Reynolds 16, WI
Edith Reynolds 14, WI
Mary Reynolds 12, WI
Vernon Reynolds 3m, WI
Cannot find any marriage record for Sarah [Douglas] Reynolds