The following is the only possibility that I found.
Died: 27 March 1887
Buried: Lake Ripley Cemetery, Cambridge, Jefferson, WI
I'd contact the Jefferson Public Library, www.jeffersonwilibrary.org/genealogy/
and the Dodge/Jefferson Counties Genealogical Society and ask about a copy of Andrew's newspaper death notice.
If he's not your Andrew, then en I'd contact the Otto Schroeder Records Center, www.danecountyhistory.org/
and ask if they have a local death index, indexed newspaper death notices and cemetery indexes. Successful Searching!