Thanks I did reach out the Venango Historical Society. They could not find Edward's naturalization papers but did find me tax records which prove he was there. They were so helpful it answering any questions I had.
Here is what they found
1807-1817 Edward owned 225 acres in Irwin twp., PA
I still do not know where the information on Margaret's surname comes from. I am attempting to have my McFadden line that reaches back to Edward designated as a first family of Ohio since they settled in Perry County in 1818 as I have his land deed from there. The tricky part is my great grandmother x3 (Mary McFadden) does not have any records that state who her parents are except biographies written, luckily not by family members. Hopefully that will be enough for the OGS!