I realize I'm responding to a very old post, but when I did a search for Benedictin Nagle, this thread popped up and I had to send you a message. Benedictin was my great-great-grandmother. She married Julius Strikmiller and they had a son, Seymour b. 1880. If you have any information about her you would like to share, I'd love to hear it. For some reason, no one in my family has ever felt comfortable discussing Seymour or his parents, so we do not have a lot of background information.
My lineage: Julius -> Seymour -> Warren -> Stephen->Scott
Thanks for your help.