I looked him up in FamilySearch and Ancestry and only found the following.
Died: 21 aug 1894
Buried: South Whitley Cemetery, South Whitley, Whitley, IN
i'd look for his death notice. The Genealogical Society Whitley County, http://whitleycountin.org/
has a lot of good info on their website but they don't do research.
The Churubusco Public Library and Peabody Public Library, might be able to help with the death notice.
Indiana didn't issue death records until 1882 and then they are no all inclusive. Successful Searching!