Do you have any info on the siblings or other relatives of Hannah Tuttle? I have a Thomas Tuttle, b. ca.1823, in Athens Co., OH. You state your Hannah Tuttle was b. 1818, in Athens Co., OH.
My Thomas Tuttle m. Mary J. Stram on 7 May 1844, in Franklin Co., OH. They had 3 children, then in 1851 they settled in Wells Co., IN, & there had 4 more children that I know of.
In the 1860 Wells Co., IN Census, an August Kenaught - 10 - M - b. IN" was found in the h.h. of Thomas Tuttle (age 37, b. OH) & wife Mary (age 36, b. OH).
NOTE: August KENAUGHT's surname should have been spelled "CARNALL".
If you, or anyone else reading this, have any connection to this Tuttle family or August Carnall, please contact me!!!