There is a Levi E. Renner on the 1880 Jay Co., IN Census. ED #208. He was the son of William D. Renner Catherine ______. He had a brother, William I. William D. was one of 10 children of Noah Renner and Francis Weaver. Please e-mail me for more info if this is your line. I am related through Abraham Renner, William D.'s brother.