Hi, Re Catherine SCOTT nee LOFTUS -married Ernest Winfield HUNTLEY
Was Catherine at the time ? or divorced?
Have you found a death for Peter SCOTT -Obituary may mention names of children
Re Death of Catherine SCOTT nee LOFTUS/ now HUNTLEY
Perhaps Obituary - may mention names of all children?
Have you searched for Birth of Peter SCOTT in Rye NY or Greenwich Conn? Marriage Registration.
Don't know about US registrations in that time frame - but may mention actual place of birth.
Early US Census may confirm residence of Peter SCOTT as an infant.