Hello! I know this is 4 years after your request for information on Charlotte Catling Noble. If you are still interested, I have quite a lot of information on her and her family. She is my ggg grandmother. I'm descended from her and Daniel Noble's son Richard who emigrated to the US in the 1860s. In all, 4 Nobles and 3 Catlings emigrated and all settled in the same area of upstate New York between 1860 and 1895. The Catlings who emigrated were Charlotte's brother James's sons. He lived in Kenninghall Norfolk.