You are here: Learn > The Library > Columnists > Dick Eastman Online

Dick Eastman Online
3/14/2001 - Archive


The Baronage Press Controversy
Speaking of online and offline genealogy scams, there is an interesting battle being fought online. The Baronage Press has produced a respectable online magazine called The Feudal Herald for several years. The Feudal Herald gives information about heraldry, the study of coats of arms, and other insignia. This magazine was instrumental in exposing companies that sold so-called "family coats of arms" and often reported on those scams. The Feudal Herald exposed several bogus "title merchants." It referred to the purveyors of false family coats of arms as "bucket shops." I read several editions of The Feudal Herald and was impressed with the quality of the reporting.

Now a newer Web site called the International Scams Magazine claims that The Baronage Press itself is a scam. The new Web site is filled with sensational claims about The Baronage Press as well as other companies. The Baronage Press has fired back with statements of "Untrue" and says that a former scammer who was unmasked by The Feudal Herald created the newer Web site. This former scammer apparently has a grudge against the company that "blew the whistle" and so has created his own Web pages filled with false claims about his attacker. In short, The Baronage Press claims the International Scams Magazine is an act of revenge.

Who is correct? Is there a real scammer here someplace? I honestly don’t know. I will say that I have read The Baronage Press for several years and have always found it to be an excellent publication that fought for accuracy and honesty. I also find it curious that the International Scams Magazine talks about "unmasking" the person or people involved and clearly identifies its enemies by name and even gives their home addresses. Yet the International Scams Magazine Web site itself never mentions the names or addresses of its own company or owners. The e-mail address for International Scams Magazine is a somewhat anonymous HotMail address. What does it have to hide?

View this online battle at Baronage Press and at International Scams. My advice? Take a grain of salt before reading either Web site.

  • Read the next article in this issue.
  • Return to the previous article in this issue.
  • Return to the Table of Contents.

  •   Printer Friendly
     
    E-mail to a friend

    Search The Library