13 May 1999

In this issue:

  • Databases of the Day
    - Floyd County, Virginia, Death Records, 1853-1882
    - Narratives of Early California: Three Years in California
    - Rocky Mountain News (Denver, Colorado), Obituaries, 1998-1999 (Update)
  • Today's Featured Map:
    - Central Britain 1715-1745
  • GenPageFinder Goes Live Wednesday, 12 May 1999
  • “Copyrights, Plagiarism, and Ethics: Rights to Use Information” by Donn Devine
    - Revised copyright laws and link to U.S. Copyright Office.
  • Thought for Today
  • Products of the Day at the Online Store
      - Ancestry Magazine
      - Genelines-New in the Online Store!
      - Confederate Military History CD-ROM


    Love talking on the phone, but hate paying the bill? Wish you could stay in touch with your whole family, but worry about the long distance costs? We have the answer! Talk long distance-online-in real time with the MyFamily.com Chat/Who's Online Messaging System. As a member of MyFamily.com, not only do you get your own FREE family Web site, you can also see which family members are online and talk to them INSTANTLY! It’s all FREE. It’s Fun. It’s all about your Family. Try it now with your family at http://www.myfamily.com/index.asp?ID=WHOS


    DATABASES OF THE DAY(Free for 10 Days!)

    Floyd County, Virginia, Death Records, 1853-1882

    Formed in 1831 from nearby Montgomery County and located southwest of Roanoke, Floyd County, Virginia was home to more than 10,000 persons in the mid-nineteenth century. This database reveals valuable information on nearly 1,800 men and women who died in the county between 1853 and 1882. It was compiled from microfilm copies of the original documents, and researchers will find the deceased person's name, race, sex, death date, cause of death, age, parents’ names, and birthplace. To those seeking Virginian ancestors, this collection can be a helpful source of information.

    Bibliography: Fridley, Beth. "Floyd Co., Virginia Death Records, 1853-1882." Orem, UT: Ancestry, Inc., 1999.

    To search this database, go to:
    http://www.ancestry.com/ancestry/search/3762.htm

    Virginia Resources in the Online Store:
    http://shop.ancestry.com/ancestry/bvirginiab.html


    Narratives of Early California: Three Years in California

    Following the Mexican-American war, California increasingly drew thousands of men and women seeking a life in the new territory. This database is the published journal of Walter Colton (1797-1851), who lived in California from 1846-1849. A distinguished member of California's high society, his florid prose recounts a number of prominent social events of the period.

    Bibliography: Library of Congress. "California As I Saw It, 1849-1900." vol. 9. [database on-line] Washington: Library of Congress, 1999. Colton, Walter. "Three Years in California." New York: A.S. Barnes & Co., 1850.

    To search this database, go to:
    http://www.ancestry.com/ancestry/search/3757.htm

    California Resources in the Online Store:
    http://shop.ancestry.com/ancestry/bcaliforniab.html


    Rocky Mountain News (Denver, Colorado), Obituaries, 1998-1999 (Update)

    Colorado's oldest newspaper, the "Rocky Mountain News" serves the over 1.6 million residents of the east-central part of the state. This database is a collection of some obituaries from the newspaper in 1998 and early 1999. Information provided often includes birth date and location, occupation, military service, surviving family members, and other biographical facts. Compiled by the UMI Company in connection with the newspaper, it contains nearly 2,500 records and about 10,000 names. For questions regarding a particular obituary, inquiries can be directed to the newspaper at 400 W. Colfax, Denver, CO, 80204, (303) 892-5000.

    This database contains new material provided by the UMI Company and previously posted material under the title “Rocky Mountain News (Denver, Colorado), Obituaries, 1998.”

    Bibliography: UMI Company. "Obituaries from the Rocky Mountain News, 1998-1999." Orem, UT: Ancestry Inc., 1999.

    To search this database, go to:
    http://www.ancestry.com/ancestry/search/3619.htm

    Colorado Resources in the Online Store:
    http://shop.ancestry.com/ancestry/bcoloradob.html


    TODAY'S FEATURED MAP

    Central Britain 1715-1745

    To view this map, go to:
    http://www.ancestry.com/whatsnew.htm

    Maps & Atlases in the Online Store
    http://shop.myfamily.com/ancestrycatalog/dept.asp?dept%5Fid=21000000

    Animap 2.0-2,000 Maps plus Place Finder Database on CD-ROM. http://shop.myfamily.com/ancestrycatalog/product.asp?dept_id=20204000&pf_id=1077611



    GENPAGEFINDER GOES LIVE Wednesday, 12 May 1999

    The world of family history on the Internet can seem like an intimidating, incomprehensible mass because it is always growing and always changing. Many researchers wonder how to make sense or use of it all. GenPageFinder is a vital part of the solution. GenPageFinder is a search engine, which currently indexes the contents of over 200,000 genealogical Web pages and is updated every week. It offers search results surrounded by their immediate context and free from non-genealogical clutter. GenPageFinder is a free service and a proud addition to the Ancestry.com Online Genealogical Library.

    GenPageFinder is now available on Ancestry.com. GenPageFinder also appears as part of the Ancestry.com GlobalSearch results. Some of the pages GenPageFinder will find are quite large. If your keywords are not immediately visible on the page GenPageFinder finds for you, try pressing Ctrl F and entering your keywords again. This should take you to the spot on the page where your keywords appear.

    Whatever your research interests and whatever searching you’ve already done, chances are that a search on GenPageFinder will yield fruitful new sources.

    Copyright Ancestry.com 1999


    “COPYRIGHTS, PLAGIARISM, AND ETHICS:
    Rights to Use Information”
    by Donn Devine

    Most of us began our family history research by gathering as much information as possible from family sources. We may have seen it as a logical way to start, or may have been fortunate in receiving sound advice on how to begin.

    Seldom does the beginner ask, "What can I properly do with what I've learned?"

    That question doesn't usually occur to us until after we have spent considerable time, effort, and money, and realize we have a substantial investment in our research. It's valuable, but to whom does it belong? More specifically, who can do what with each part of it?

    Looking at genealogical research in the abstract, we see that its subject matter has two components- facts, which are impressions about reality that come to us through our senses and are stored in our short-term or long-term memories, and our thoughts and ideas, which give the facts significance. Facts and ideas together constitute knowledge.

    Knowledge is also called intellectual property, a term that recognizes that it resides in people's intellects and that it has real value. Even though intellectual property is intangible, the use of it is regulated both by law and by well-developed ethical principles that apply to scholarly activity.

    USE OF FACTS AND IDEAS

    Once knowledge is expressed outside the mind, both laws and ethical standards regulate its use. A record of someone's own thoughts, made solely as a memory aid, with no intention of communicating it to someone else, belongs to that person, along with the knowledge recorded. Both the record and the knowledge it reflects enjoy legal protection like other property of its owner.

    If the record also includes someone else's knowledge that is not generally known to others, that knowledge continues to belong to the original owner, and it remains subject to any restrictions the original owner placed on its further use.

    It's not until a person decides to share knowledge with others-the processes of communication, publication, or presentation-that the question arises about ownership of the knowledge. At that point, various laws and ethical standards come into effect, which give the original holder some rights and control over the uses that others can make of the knowledge.

    PRIVACY LAW RESTRICTIONS

    The law of privacy is one that every family historian needs to understand. It protects living people from having details of their private lives made public unless they have done something to place themselves in the public eye, such as taking an office or position in which there's a legitimate public interest, or being involved in a crime or accident. The kinds of information protected include the very things we're interested in for family history-age, residence, occupation, relationships, and associations.

    Living people who are not already public figures have a right to keep personal information about themselves private, and they can collect legal damages, just as for a physical injury, if anyone violates that right. If your staid and proper elderly aunt was once a burlesque queen, you reveal the fact at your peril unless you have her permission-and preferably in writing, in case there's any question later.

    Other privacy laws of recent origin prohibit keepers of certain records, most of them governmental, from releasing personal information. These laws are directed at the record-keepers, and provide penalties if they are violated, but usually don't affect use of the same information obtained from other sources. Records that are coming under such privacy restrictions include birth, marriage, and death registrations for some years after the event, and records relating to adoption, schooling, employment, criminal activity, and health.

    RESTRICTIONS BY AGREEMENT

    Facts can't belong to anyone. However, someone who has exclusive knowledge of a fact can set conditions and restrictions on its future use. If your dear old aunt confided in you, with the condition, "but don't tell anyone," that Grandpa died of a heart attack in a house of ill repute, you have gained the same knowledge she had, but if you share it with anyone else, you have violated your agreed terms, and she may legally collect damages as for any other breach of contract.

    Similarly, someone who has assembled a collection of facts and organized it in some useful way can place restrictions on further use of the facts as a condition of allowing others to use the collection. A typical example is a mailing list. People who pay to use addresses from commercial mailing lists usually have to agree that they will not keep copies of the addresses, nor make any further use of them. Subscribers to online database services are usually required to accept strict conditions on the use they may make of data they retrieve. Such agreements are binding on those who make them, and can be enforced by law, but they don't affect people who may have come by the information by accident.

    COPYRIGHT LAW RESTRICTIONS

    Copyright is among the best-known forms of intellectual property protection, and family historians need to be aware of its effects. While it can protect our own work, it also limits the use we can make of others' work. To encourage authors to make their works available to the public, copyright law gives authors the exclusive right, over a number of years, to copy, publish, present, or display the work; to make derivative works, such as translations or condensations; or to assign those rights to others as they see fit.

    The period of copyright protection for works created since 1978 is the life of the author plus fifty years. For earlier works, the initial period was twenty-eight years, and it could formerly be extended for a second twenty-eight years. The renewal period has now been increased to forty-seven years, providing a total copyright term of seventy-five years, if the copyright is renewed before the end of the initial twenty-eight-year term. After the copyright has expired, the work is in the public domain, and can be freely used by anyone. Before that, you need permission to quote extracts. (SEE EDITOR’S NOTE AT THE BOTTOM OF THIS ARTICLE FOR LINKS TO UPDATED COPYRIGHT TERMS.)

    It is important to understand that copyright does not protect the use of facts or ideas, but only the originality with which they are expressed in a particular work. The form of the expression can be a written or printed document, a dramatic or musical composition, a graphic image in two or three dimensions, or an electronic recording, among other forms.

    Under current U.S. copyright law, copyright in a work exists from the time it is reduced to a form that can be perceived by the senses, even before it is shared with anyone else. The writer of a letter or an e-mail message has a copyright on that particular expression of an idea as soon as it is written; this copyright lasts the rest of the author's life, and for fifty years thereafter. During that period, it is a violation of the author's rights to pass the writing on to someone else without permission.

    However, there's no violation of the copyright if another person takes the same idea and expresses it in another form, so long as it is sufficiently different from the first work that it represents an original expression in its own right.

    No matter how much time and effort has gone into compiling a work, there must also be some originality in its arrangement or expression for copyright protection to apply. An alphabetical index of names, for example, without some further innovative or creative features, would probably not qualify.

    OTHER LEGAL RESTRICTIONS

    Patents and trademarks are other forms of legal protection for intellectual property protection, although they have limited application to family history. Patents protect useful inventions-practical ideas that may have value in the marketplace-and give the inventor exclusive use of the idea for a limited period, in exchange for making it public. Trademarks identify the providers of products or services, and are protected to prevent frauds on the public.

    ETHICAL CONCERNS

    Copyright law does not protect an author against having his facts and ideas used by someone else without credit, so long as the person who appropriates them uses different words to express them. But while it may be legal, it's not right, as most of us learned in high school composition. To take the ideas of another without credit and present them as your own is called plagiarism, and is perhaps the most serious offense a person can commit in the world of intellectual or scholarly work.

    In an academic setting, plagiarism is grounds for dismissal of a faculty member or expulsion of a student, whatever the motivation may have been. In my own undergraduate days, it happened to a quixotic older student, a returning veteran of the Second World War who was in his early thirties and close to graduation. He had taken an essay by an early twentieth-century English writer of some note, given it a new title with himself as author, and submitted it to the undergraduate literary magazine. It went through the usual review by student editors and English faculty and was published as his. An alert reader quickly brought its true author to the attention of university authorities. At his disciplinary hearing, the offending student said he had submitted the article as his own only to demonstrate that people in the English department were not well-read. He was expelled anyway.

    In the federal government, the current official standards on research misconduct require proof of intent before an offense can be punished as misconduct. You probably would not lose a research grant or be dismissed from employment for plagiarism unless it was proved that you deliberately intended to appropriate someone else's work as your own-as opposed, say, to having carelessly failed to properly attribute it. But plagiarism is primarily a matter of ethics, whatever the legal findings, and your reputation among other researchers would not likely survive, even if you kept your job.

    In short, it is plagiarism, a major ethical offense, to use the ideas and research results of others without attributing them to the original researchers. It is also a major ethical offense to present them deceptively or inaccurately, even if properly attributed.

    EXCEPTIONS TO COPYRIGHT RESTRICTIONS

    Generally, the copyright law prohibits any use whatever of a copyrighted work, whether published or not, without the copyright owner's permission. However, the law does carve out a few limited exceptions in the interest of encouraging scholarship.

    The principal one, widely used by family historians, is the "fair use" exception, which allows some limited use of copyrighted works without permission. Under it, an individual can make copies from a copyrighted work for personal use, or a teacher for classroom use. The limits of "fair use" aren't defined, but factors that help determine them include the number of copies, how large a portion of the work is copied, whether there is a charge for them, and whether the copying substitutes for purchase of the published work. You can also use limited quotations from a copyrighted work in the context of scholarly or critical comment on them.

    Libraries and archives enjoy a somewhat broader scope under the "fair use" exception. They can, for example, copy entire books or articles for interlibrary loan or to replace out-of-print works.

    However, making copies is hardly fair when it lowers the demand for a readily available publication, depriving the publisher of income and the author of royalties. Would you want this to happen to your own book or pamphlet?

    THE TEST

    If all the information you plan to share came from your own research into public records, you can share it without fear of violating someone else's rights. But if some of your information came from people, publications, or privately owned documents, take a second look-there may be legal or ethical restrictions or conditions on its use.


    Editor’s Note: This article originally appeared in the Jan/Feb 1998 issue of Ancestry Magazine (vol. 16, no. 1). (Ancestry magazine subscriptions are available at the reduced rate of $19.95 for a limited time. Click http://shop.myfamily.com/ancestrycatalog/dept.asp?dept%5Fid=30000000 for more information.)

    Since the time of its publication, there have been changes to copyright law, in particular to the copyright terms. From the U.S. Copyright Office page at: http://lcweb.loc.gov/copyright/circs/sl15.pdf (Acrobat Reader is required to view this site.)

    “The Sonny Bono Copyright Term Extension Act, signed into law on October 27, 1998, amends the provisions concerning duration of copyright protection. Effective immediately, the terms of copyright are generally extended for an additional 20 years. Specific provisions are as follows:”

    “For works created after January 1, 1978, copyright protection will endure for the life of the author plus an additional 70 years. In the case of a joint work, the term lasts for 70 years after the last surviving author’s death. For anonymous and pseudonymous works and works made for hire, the term will be 95 years from the year of first publication or 120 years from the year of creation, whichever expires first.”

    “For works created but not published or registered before January 1, 1978, the term endures for life of the author plus 70 years, but in no case will expire earlier than December 31, 2002. If the work is published before December 31, 2002, the term will not expire before December 31, 2047.”

    “For pre-1978 works still in their original or renewal term of copyright, the total term is extended to 95 years from the date that copyright was originally secured. There are additional provisions regarding sound recordings made before February 15, 1972, termination of grants and licenses, presumption of an author’s death, and reproduction by libraries and archives. For further information about these provisions, call the Public Information Office, Monday through Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., Eastern Time, except federal holidays, at 202-707-3000. You may view this legislation at the Copyright Office Web site at: http://www.loc.gov/copyright/legislation/s505.pdf “ (Acrobat Reader is required to view this site.)

    More information is available at the U.S. Copyright Office site at: http://lcweb.loc.gov/copyright/


    THOUGHT FOR TODAY

    “America was discovered accidentally by a great seaman who was looking for something else . . . and most of the exploration for the next fifty years was done in the hope of getting through or around it. American was named after a man who discovered no part of the New World. History is like that, very chancy.”

    - Samuel Eliot Morison, 1887-1976
    “The Oxford History of the American People” (1965)


    PRODUCT OF THE DAY AT THE ONLINE STORE

    ANCESTRY MAGAZINE SPECIAL
    http://shop.myfamily.com/ancestrycatalog/dept.asp?dept%5Fid=30000000
    Get a bimonthly boost of genealogy news, views, and how-to's with Ancestry Magazine. Only $19.95 now for a limited time.


    INTRODUCING GENELINES--a brand new way to look back at your ancestors!! Genelines helps you place your ancestors in a historical context, which gives you new insight about the events and relationships that shaped their lives. By visually mapping ancestors and family groups against a historical timeline you can powerfully envision how their lives intersected and how events on the world stage may have impacted their decisions and life circumstances. Find out more at: http://shop.myfamily.com/ancestrycatalog/product.asp?dept_id=20102000&pf_id=1104011


    CONFEDERATE MILITARY HISTORY CD-ROM
    http://shop.myfamily.com/ancestrycatalog/product.asp?dept_id=20202000&pf_id=1096211


    For Civil War history buffs and genealogists who want to better understand the whys and wherefores of secession as well as the historical context in which their southern (or for that matter, northern) ancestors lived, Confederate Military History is a must! This important CD-ROM contains twelve volumes of confederate perspectives on the War Between the States.

    Normally the Confederate Military History CD retails for $39.95, but today you can buy it in the Ancestry.com Online Store for only $33.95.


    These prices will be effective until Friday, 14 May, 8 A.M. Mountain Time.

    You can see a full description, and order today's products through Ancestry's Online Store at: http://shop.ancestry.com.
    Stay tuned for more savings!


    Best Wishes,
    Juliana Smith, Editor, Ancestry Daily News
    Rebekah Thorstenson, Associate Editor
    Please feel free to circulate this newsletter to other genealogy enthusiasts! We hope that you will also credit the Daily News as the source.
    To subscribe to this newsletter, visit http://www.ancestry.com/whatsnew.htm and type your Email address in the box provided, or send an email message to: ancestry_daily_news@anclist001.ancestry.com with the word ‘subscribe’ in the subject line. For comments or submissions to the Daily News email: editor@ancestry-inc.com